Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
Art market16 Nov 2026

Eight of nine paintings like it sold above estimate. Will the Van Gogh?

Sotheby's sells Van Gogh's Chestnut Trees in Blossom in New York on 18 November. Heirs of a former owner say it was sold under Nazi pressure.

4 min read

What happened

While our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress, we recognise the importance of engaging thoughtfully and constructively with the family and are committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution.

Sotheby’s sells twelve paintings from one collection in New York on . An Argentine couple bought most of them in the 1970s. The top painting is Vincent van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom), which Sotheby’s expects to sell for about $180m. The highest price paid for a Van Gogh at auction so far is $117m.

Heirs of a former owner say the Van Gogh was sold under Nazi pressure. Samuel Fischer, a German publisher, bought the painting in 1909. A lawyer for his heirs wrote to Sotheby’s that it was sold in Amsterdam before the Second World War, after the Nazis caused heavy losses to the family’s publishing company.

Sotheby’s takes provenance and restitution matters extremely seriously and has undertaken extensive research into the ownership history of Châtaigniers en fleurs. We are aware of the concerns recently raised by representatives of the Fischer heirs and have been in dialogue with them regarding the painting’s history.

Sotheby’s statement to the BBC, 14 November 2026

Sotheby’s says its own research does not show the sale was forced. It also says it is “committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution” with the family. The New York Times reported that Sotheby’s would meet the heirs’ lawyers on , two days before the sale. If Sotheby’s pulls the painting, it does not sell on the night.

The same sale has Paul Cézanne’s Arlequin, a portrait of his son. Sotheby’s gives no estimate for it on its website and gives one only on request. In 2022 a Cézanne sold at auction for $137.8m, a record for the artist. The Guardian writes that both paintings may sell for the highest prices yet for each artist.

Sources: BBC, The Guardian, The New York Times (2), Sotheby's, Christie's

The Pattern

We looked for cases where Christie’s, Sotheby’s or Phillips offered a painting at auction with a published estimate of $100m or more, at or above the highest auction price for that artist. We found nine such paintings since 2015, all sold in New York. Christie’s sold eight of them, and three came from one collection on one night in 2022. Prices include the fee the buyer pays on top of the winning bid.

8 of 9
Eight of nine times a painting estimated at or above the artist's highest auction price sold above its estimate, buyer's fee included, and once it sold below it.
2026 Christie's, Pollockheld
: Jackson Pollock’s Number 7A, 1948 was estimated at about $100m, above his auction high of $61.2m. It sold for $181.2m.
2025 Sotheby's, Klimtheld
: Gustav Klimt’s portrait of Elisabeth Lederer was estimated at over $150m, above his auction high of $108m. It sold for $236.4m.
Show the other 7 cases
2022 Christie's, Seuratheld
, from the collection of Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen: Georges Seurat’s Les Poseuses was estimated at over $100m. It sold for $149.2m, three times his auction high.
2022 Christie's, Cézanneheld
Same night, same collection: Paul Cézanne’s La Montagne Sainte-Victoire was estimated at over $100m. It sold for $137.8m, twice his earlier auction high.
2022 Christie's, Van Goghheld
Same night, same collection: Van Gogh’s Verger avec cyprès was estimated at over $100m, above his auction high of $83m from 1990. It sold for $117.2m.
2022 Christie's, Warholnot held
: Andy Warhol’s Shot Sage Blue Marilyn was estimated at about $200m, almost twice his auction high of $105m. It sold for $195m, below the estimate.
2017 Christie's, Leonardoheld
: Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi was estimated at about $100m, and Christie’s promised the seller that sum. It sold for $450.3m, the most paid for any work at auction.
2015 Christie's, Modiglianiheld
: Amedeo Modigliani’s Nu couché was estimated at over $100m, far above his earlier auction high. It sold for $170.4m.
2015 Christie's, Picassoheld
: Pablo Picasso’s Les femmes d’Alger was estimated at over $140m, above his auction high of $106.5m. It sold for $179.4m.

The Read

All nine paintings sold on the night, and each set a new high for its artist. Eight went above their estimate. The one that fell short, Andy Warhol’s Marilyn in 2022, still sold for $195m against an estimate of about $200m. For the Van Gogh the estimate and the $180m line are the same number, so a price just at the estimate is not enough. In 2022 two of the three Paul Allen paintings sold close to their estimate.

There are reasons for doubt. None of the nine paintings faced a claim from heirs days before the sale. Christie’s sold eight of the nine, and three came from one collection on one night. For the Cézanne there is no published estimate, and $140m is $2.2m above the Cézanne record set in 2022.

Sources: Christie's, Christie's, The Guardian (2), BBC, BBC, Sotheby's

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.