The Guardian's critic and the most tipped artist differ on the Turner Prize
Four artists are on the Turner Prize shortlist, on show in Middlesbrough. Tate names the winner on 10 December.
What happened
On the Guardian’s review of the Turner Prize show at MIMA, Middlesbrough, said Kira Freije’s figures “trounce everything in their path” and called Tanoa Sasraku “by far the least giving artist here”.
The four artists on this year’s Turner Prize shortlist are Simeon Barclay, Kira Freije, Marguerite Humeau and Tanoa Sasraku. Their work is on show at MIMA in Middlesbrough from . Tate will name the winner on . The winner gets £25,000 and the others £10,000 each.
A jury of five, chaired by Alex Farquharson, the director of Tate Britain, chooses the winner. The prize is for an earlier exhibition, not for the show in Middlesbrough. Sasraku is nominated for Morale Patch at the ICA in London, and Freije for Unspeak the Chorus at The Hepworth Wakefield. (Tate, 25 Sep 2026)
Jonathan Jones reviewed the show for the Guardian. He wrote: “The moment I saw Freije’s room I wanted her to win.” He called Sasraku “by far the least giving artist here”.
Prospect’s critic saw it the other way. He called Sasraku’s Watchlist, glass paperweights filled with crude oil, “the strongest work in the show”, and Barclay’s room probably the weakest.
Sasraku is the most tipped to win, well ahead of the other three. Since the show opened, Barclay has moved up to second and Freije has slipped to third.
Sources: The Guardian, Tate (2), Prospect, OLBG price list
The Pattern
We looked for cases where the Turner Prize show took place outside London, as it does this year, and the Guardian’s main art critic named the artist who should win when the show opened. Then we checked who was most tipped at that time. We found eight years, from 2007 to 2025. The critic’s pick won in three. The most tipped also won in three, though in three years who was most tipped is not on record.
Show the other 6 cases
The Read
History gives no clear favourite. The Guardian critic’s pick won three of eight times, and so did the most tipped. Four times, the winner was someone neither had named. When the two disagreed, as they do now, it went one each way: the most tipped won in 2017, the critic’s pick in 2025.
Who counts as the main critic is our choice, and this year it is a different person. Adrian Searle, who wrote the Guardian review in all eight years, stepped down in , and Jonathan Jones wrote this year’s review. (The Guardian, 31 Mar 2026) Who was most tipped when the show opened is on record in only five of the eight years.
One institution decided all eight. Tate runs the prize, the director of Tate Britain chairs the jury each year, and the jury judges an earlier exhibition, not the show the critics review. The record is short and comes from one prize.
Disclaimer
Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.
Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.
