Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch

Saba wants three seats on the Baillie Gifford US Growth board. Will it get one?

Saba has put three of its people up for the board of Baillie Gifford US Growth. The other shareholders decide on 23 October.

5 min read

What happened

On the board of Baillie Gifford US Growth Trust called its annual meeting for and asked shareholders to vote against three Saba candidates for the board.

On Saba Capital asked Baillie Gifford US Growth Trust (BG US Growth) to put three of its people up for the board: Jason Chen, Thomas McGlade and James Waterlow. The request came through a nominee company and is for the trust’s annual meeting. The board told shareholders to take no action.

The annual meeting is at 1pm on in London. The board is unanimously against Saba’s three resolutions. It says it offered Saba a cash exit several times at asset value less the cost of selling holdings, about 99.75% of asset value, with Baillie Gifford paying the other costs. Saba turned it down each time.

The board says shareholders have voted Saba down before. If the three resolutions fail, it will go back to Saba about a cash exit close to asset value, open to Saba and any other shareholder who wants to leave.

Saba owns about 29% of the £1bn trust. Tim Campbell, chief executive of Baillie Gifford, told The Herald that a Saba win would be sad for the trust’s other holders. He said most of them are retail savers, many do not vote, and funds that tend to follow Saba are also on the register.

Sources: BG US Growth (2), The Herald

The Pattern

We looked for cases where an activist with a large stake in an investment trust, but less than half, put its own people up for the board at a set meeting, and the board and the manager were against. We found ten, nine of them Saba’s, from 2015 to 2026. The activist got seats in two.

2 of 10
In 2 of 10 cases the activist got seats on the board, once by a vote and once by a deal. Seven of the ten came from one round of Saba meetings in early 2025, so the ten cases hold four separate decisions.
2026 Edinburgh Worldwide, Apr 2026held
, annual meeting, Saba’s third try. The board had promised a tender for half the shares. Saba and three other US funds held over 40%. Saba’s three candidates won about 63%; five directors lost their seats. (Edinburgh Worldwide (RNS))
2026 Edinburgh Worldwide, Jan 2026not held
, meeting called by Saba, its second try. Turnout was a record; 53.2% voted against Saba’s candidates, and 92.7% of other holders were against. Saba lost. (Edinburgh Worldwide (RNS))
Show the other 8 cases
2025 Edinburgh Worldwide, Feb 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba, its first try at this trust. 63.8% voted against its plan to remove six directors and add two. Saba lost. (Edinburgh Worldwide (RNS))
2025 European Smaller Cos, 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba. 62.1% voted against; without Saba’s shares, 99.5% were against. Saba lost. (European Smaller Companies Trust (RNS))
2025 Henderson Opportunities, 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba. The board had offered a plan with a cash exit at asset value. 65.36% voted against; outside Saba, under 1% voted for. Saba lost. (Henderson Opportunities Trust (RNS))
2025 CQS Natural Resources, 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba, which held 29.07%. About 59% voted against; without Saba’s shares, 98.6% were against. Saba lost. (CQS Natural Resources (RNS))
2025 BG US Growth, Feb 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba at this same trust. 65.6% voted against on a 78.4% turnout; without Saba’s shares, about 98.5% were against. Saba lost. (BG US Growth (RNS))
2025 Keystone Positive Change, 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba. The board had already offered a cash exit with no limit. Between 60.33% and 60.55% voted against. Saba lost. (Keystone Positive Change (RNS))
2025 Herald Investment Trust, 2025not held
, meeting called by Saba. 65.10% voted against; outside Saba, only 0.15% voted for. Saba lost. (Herald Investment Trust (RNS))
2015 Alliance Trust, Elliott, 2015held
: Elliott, owner of 12%, put up three candidates for the annual meeting, and the board fought them. On the board appointed two of the three, and Elliott dropped its resolutions. (Reuters (via Investing.com))

The Read

History is against Saba: the activist got seats in 2 of 10 cases. The ten are less than they look. Seven were one round of meetings Saba called in early 2025, and it lost all seven, including a first try at this trust in , where 65.6% voted against it.

The two wins share a feature. Both came at annual meetings, where sitting directors must stand again, and all eight losses came at meetings Saba called itself. The vote is an annual meeting. That rests on two cases, so it moves our estimate but does not replace History.

Outside Saba, holders voted almost as one against it in every loss where the trusts gave the figure. The one win came after three other US funds joined Saba, together over 40% of the shares. Baillie Gifford’s chief executive says funds of that kind are on the BG US Growth register too.

The trust will publish the vote on the London Stock Exchange news service on . A deal before the meeting, as at Alliance Trust in 2015, would settle the seat question early.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.