Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
Market29 Sep 2026

Is the new US car mileage rule taken to court within a week?

BinaryResolves 16 Oct 2026
History5 of 5
Hunch40%
Your forecast
  • Yes
  • No
Resolved
Resolved: YES

The SAFE III rule was published in the Federal Register on 30 September 2026 and on 2 October 2026 the NRDC (Second Circuit, 26-2781) and the Center for Biological Diversity with Sierra Club and others (D.C. Circuit, 26-1261) filed petitions for review, according to CourtListener court records.

Resolved 2 Oct 2026
Why these numbers

History. 5 of 5. The first challenge came 7 days before publication in 2019, on the day itself in 2018, 2019 and 2026, and the day after in 2019.

Hunch.

  • For: The Sierra Club vowed to fight the rule (The Guardian, 28 Sep 2026).
  • For: Where the law sends challenges straight to an appeals court, campaign groups filed on the day of publication in 2019 and 2026.
  • Against: The same agency's fuel rules were first challenged on day 27 in 2020 (California Attorney General petition, 27 May 2020) and on day 59 in 2022 (states' opening brief).
  • Against: No US state had said it would sue over this rule by 29 September (California Attorney General news page, 29 Sep 2026).
How this resolves

The one-week market resolves on the court records in CourtListener and the attorneys general's press releases: YES if any state, city or group files a court challenge to the rule no later than the seventh day after it appears in the Federal Register. If the rule has not appeared in the Federal Register by 9 October 2026 the market is void, and Reuters and AP reports of the filing are the backup.

The pattern behind it

5 of 5
In 5 of 5 cases the first court challenge came by the day after the rule was published. States were in court within 36 days in all five.

We looked for cases where a new US government cancelled or weakened a binding rule made under a government of the other party, and opponents said in public, before the new rule came out, that they would go to court. We found five such cases, all since 2018. In every one, the first court challenge was filed by the day after the rule appeared in the Federal Register.