Afghans in the US lost their protection. Can Democrats force a vote to restore it?
Jason Crow and Sam Liccardo need 218 names to force a US House vote on protection for Afghans. By 12 November they had 114.
What happened
Crow and Liccardo would need all current House Democrats and a handful of Republicans to sign on to their discharge petition to reach the necessary 218 signatures.
A rule of the US House lets members force a vote without their leaders. Normally the leaders of the party with the most seats, now the Republicans, decide which bills come to a vote. Under rule XV, any member can start a discharge petition, a public list of names kept by the Clerk of the House. If 218 members sign, a majority of the House, any of them can bring the bill to a vote after the House has sat for seven more days.
On two Democrats started such a list for Afghans. Jason Crow of Colorado and Sam Liccardo of California want a vote on their bill to give Afghans in the US Temporary Protected Status (TPS) until . TPS lets people from unsafe countries live and work in the US without fear of deportation. President Donald Trump’s government ended it for Afghanistan in , and last week a federal judge stopped, for now, a plan to send dozens of Afghans to Pakistan.
in support of which motion the undersigned Members of the House of Representatives affix their signatures
Discharge Petition No. 28, Office of the Clerk, US House of Representatives,
Republicans hold 218 seats and Democrats 214. One member sits as an independent and two seats are empty, so even with every Democrat the list needs some Republicans. Four Republicans formally back the bill: Don Bacon, Maria Elvira Salazar, Joe Wilson and Morgan Luttrell, and the independent Kevin Kiley supports it. By the list had 114 names: 112 Democrats, Bacon, who signed on the first day, and Brian Fitzpatrick, who signed on .
Time is short. This Congress ends at noon on , and the House sits this week and next before a break for Thanksgiving, then again from to and from 8 to . CBS News projects that Democrats will hold most seats in the new Congress, but Liccardo said “This cannot wait until the Democratic majority takes over”.
Sources: NBC News, US House Clerk, House Rules and Manual, US House, CBS News
The Pattern
We looked for cases where the smaller party in the US House started a petition, needed only a few votes from the other side, and the bill already had enough backers from the bigger party to close that gap. We found five such petitions from 2024 to 2026, each started after at least two others had reached 218 in the same Congress.
Show the other 3 cases
The Read
One of the five lists reached 218 within 55 days, the time this petition has. The two lists that got there at all moved fast at the start, with 138 names by the third day and 157 on the first, and a Republican signed within two weeks. This list had 105 names by its third day and 114 by its fourth, when Fitzpatrick became the second Republican. The two lists started after the 2024 election, in the last weeks of a Congress, never got a Republican name.
There are reasons for doubt. Both lists that reached 218 came from this same Congress and the same Republican leaders. In this Congress Democrats also led three other petitions that reached 218, among them one on TPS for Haitians, which took 64 days. In April that bill passed the House 224 to 204, with 10 Republicans voting yes. Another Democratic petition, on immigration status, has had every Democrat and three Republicans since and is still one name short.
Disclaimer
Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.
Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.
