Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US border5 Oct 2026

A judge stopped Trump's wall in a Texas national park. Will his team fight back?

A federal judge in Texas has stopped border wall building in the Big Bend region while a lawsuit goes on. The border agency is weighing next steps.

5 min read

What happened

US district judge Kathleen Cardone temporarily blocked the Trump administration from building border wall and other security works across the Big Bend region of west Texas on .

On Judge Kathleen Cardone stopped border building in Big Bend, a remote region of west Texas with a popular national park. Until the case is decided, the border agency may not build or dig there unless it follows the environmental and heritage laws the government had set aside. She found that the people suing were likely to win and would suffer harm that cannot be undone.

The government had used special powers to move fast. The Department of Homeland Security waived dozens of such laws to speed up the work. A church group, the Center for Biological Diversity and a river guide sued to overturn those waivers.

Work had already begun. Bulldozers cut new roads in the park in August, the border agency paused for a short time, and work started again in September. Wall panels went up nearby in Hudspeth county from . The agency has given contracts worth more than $6bn for the region.

Opposition crosses party lines. Landowners, sheriffs and politicians from both parties object, and one lawsuit says the region sees only about 1% of border arrests.

The government has not said whether it will appeal. A border agency spokesperson said: “We stand by our assessment and remain confident in our legal authorities”, and added that the agency is “working with the Department of Justice on next steps”.

Sources: The Guardian (2), Reuters, US District Court, Western District of Texas, docket, Al Jazeera

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a government was building under emergency or national security powers that set normal rules aside, work had started, and a judge then stopped it until the case was decided. We found four since 2022. Three are in the United States and two involve the Trump administration. The White House ballroom case of 2026 is the one the count rests on: without it there would be only three.

3 of 4
In 3 of 4 cases the government asked a higher court to pause the ban, within 0 to 14 days. In the fourth, Mexico in 2022, it restarted the work under a new national security order instead.
2026 US, White House ballroomheld
: a judge stopped the White House ballroom. The White House said it needed no approval from Congress, then called the work vital for national security. It appealed on ; a pause came on . (The Guardian)
2025 US, Florida migrant campheld
: a judge ordered the Florida Everglades migrant camp, built under emergency powers, to wind down in 60 days. The governments appealed, and on the appeals court paused the order 2 to 1. (The Guardian)
Show the other 2 cases
2023 US, Texas river barrierheld
: a judge ordered Texas to move its floating Rio Grande barrier, put there without federal permission and defended as a shield against invasion. Texas appealed and the appeals court paused the order. (US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit)
2022 Mexico, Maya Trainnot held
: a judge halted work on part of Mexico’s Maya Train without environmental permits. The government did not appeal. On its security council made the train a national security project and work went on. (BBC News)

The Read

History points to a fight in a higher court. In three of four cases the government asked a higher court to lift the ban within two weeks, and each time the first answer was a pause. In the fourth, Mexico did not appeal but restarted work under a new national security order. This time the border agency says it is working with the Department of Justice on next steps, it had already told the court on that its own pause was over, and it has more than $6bn of contracts in the region.

The route may be slower here. The law the government used to waive the rules says such rulings can be reviewed only by the Supreme Court, through a special petition, so a request may take longer than in the cases. The record is also thin. It has four cases, two involve this administration, and one count rests on the White House ballroom case, where the government relied first on the president’s own powers and only later on national security. Work also needs land, and many Big Bend landowners still refuse.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.