Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch

Argentina asks a sea court to block Falklands oil drilling. Will the judges agree?

Judges in Hamburg heard Argentina and Britain on 10 and 11 November. Argentina wants new oil drilling near the Falkland Islands blocked.

5 min read

What happened

Britain and Argentina clash at the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in Hamburg over the Sea Lion oil project near the Falkland Islands.

The International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) heard Argentina and Britain in Hamburg on 10 and . On Argentina asked the tribunal for an urgent order against Britain in a dispute over oil near the Falkland Islands. Such an order stays in force after a separate five-member panel, which will hear the whole dispute, is set up. That panel can then change or end it.

The target is Sea Lion, an oilfield about 220km from the islands run by Israel’s Navitas Petroleum and Britain’s Rockhopper Exploration. Drilling is due to start in and oil to flow from 2028. Without an order, that plan stays in place.

the United Kingdom shall take all necessary measures to ensure that no new drilling for exploitation, and no installation of production infrastructure, takes place in the North Malvinas Basin in connection with the project known as “Sea Lion”

Argentina, final request to ITLOS,

Britain asks the tribunal to turn the request down in full. Attorney General Ellie Reeves said the order would have “devastating consequences” for the islanders, who could lose billions of pounds. Britain says the dispute is really about who owns the islands, which is not for this tribunal. Asked if Britain would obey a ruling, Reeves said she would not “get ahead” of the decisions.

On Britain promised the tribunal in writing that drilling will not start before . Argentina says that date has no proof and that a drilling rig is reportedly due in .

The tribunal plans to read its order on Saturday . Its president set that date when the hearing closed on , and said the two countries would be told in good time if it changes.

Sources: The Guardian (2), ITLOS (2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7), Al Jazeera

The Pattern

We looked for cases where one country asked ITLOS for an urgent order against another, while the panel that would hear the full dispute was not yet set up. We found eight such orders since 1999. Four were about ships and crews seized by the other country and one about charges against two marines. Only three were about a country’s work at sea, like Sea Lion. (ITLOS)

6 of 8
In six of eight such requests the tribunal told the other country to stop at least part of what was asked, and twice it ordered only cooperation.
2019 Switzerland v Nigeria, tankerheld
2019: Switzerland asked the tribunal to free a tanker and its crew detained by Nigeria. The court ordered their release once Switzerland paid a $14m bond, 14 days after the hearings.
2019 Ukraine v Russia, navy shipsheld
2019: Ukraine asked the tribunal to free three navy ships and 24 crew detained by Russia, which stayed away. The court ordered their release 15 days after the hearing, but did not stop the criminal cases.
Show the other 6 cases
2015 Italy v India, marinesheld
2015: Italy asked the tribunal to stop India’s court case against two Italian marines. The court told both countries to pause all court cases, 13 days after the hearings, but kept limits on their travel.
2013 Netherlands v Russia, shipheld
2013: The Netherlands asked the tribunal to free the ship Arctic Sunrise and its crew, detained by Russia, which stayed away. The court ordered their release after a €3.6m bond, 16 days after the hearing.
2012 Argentina v Ghana, navy shipheld
2012: Argentina asked the tribunal to free its navy ship ARA Libertad, detained in a port in Ghana. The court ordered Ghana to let it go at once and with no conditions, 15 days after the hearings.
2003 Malaysia v Singapore, new landnot held
2003: Malaysia asked the tribunal to stop Singapore building new land in the sea near their border. The court set up a group of experts and told Singapore to avoid serious harm. The work went on.
2001 Ireland v UK, Sellafield plantnot held
2001: Ireland asked the tribunal to stop a new nuclear fuel plant at Sellafield in England. The court ordered only talks and shared data, 13 days after the hearings, and wrote down Britain’s promises.
1999 Australia, NZ v Japan, tunaheld
1999: Australia and New Zealand asked the tribunal to stop Japan’s extra fishing for bluefin tuna. The court told all three to hold off unless they agreed or kept within limits, 7 days after the hearings.

The Read

Most past orders told a country to stop at least part of what was asked. Four of those six were about ships and crews seized by the other country, and one about charges against two marines. In the three requests about a country’s work at sea, the tribunal stopped the work once, in the 1999 tuna dispute, and only with a condition. In 2001, when Ireland made such a request against Britain, the court stopped nothing and wrote Britain’s promises into its order.

Britain has made a similar promise this time. It says drilling will not start before , and expects the full panel to be set up by at the latest. Argentina says a panel that new could not act in time. Britain also argues the dispute is about who owns the islands, which none of the eight earlier orders faced. In 2015, in a drilling dispute between Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire that a chamber of the same tribunal also decided in full, the tribunal ordered no new drilling.

Sources: ITLOS (2, 3, 4, 5, 6)

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.