Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
UK by-elections30 Jun 2026

Greater Manchester picks Andy Burnham's successor. Labour has won every mayor race.

Greater Manchester elects a new mayor on 30 July after Andy Burnham went back to Westminster. Labour's Bev Craig defends a post Labour has never lost.

4 min read

What happened

The full candidate list for the Greater Manchester mayoral by-election is confirmed: seven names, with Labour’s Bev Craig and Reform UK’s Sian Astley the principals.

Andy Burnham won the Makerfield by-election on . The Greater Manchester mayor also holds the powers of a police and crime commissioner and cannot sit as an MP, so Burnham resigned as mayor on . That started a by-election for mayor on . The winner serves until the next regular mayoral election in .

Labour moved fast and named Bev Craig, leader of Manchester City Council since 2021, as its candidate on . Reform UK chose Sian Astley, a recently elected councillor for Baguley.

The Greens are running Geraldine Coggins, their group leader in Trafford. The Conservatives are running Phil Eckersley, Trafford deputy leader, and the Liberal Democrats Richard Kilpatrick, a councillor for Didsbury West. Marlon West of Restore Britain completes the list.

This vote goes back to the supplementary vote system. Voters mark a first and a second choice. If no candidate gets more than 50% of first choices, the top two go to a second count, where second choices are added. Every earlier Greater Manchester mayoral election except 2024 used this system, and in all three Burnham won on first choices alone.

Sources: Manchester City Council, House of Commons Library, LabourList, Greater Manchester Combined Authority

The Pattern

Labour has won all three Greater Manchester mayor races. Each win was big, and each one was Andy Burnham’s. We also show two recent by-elections in the North West, Runcorn in 2025 and Makerfield in 2026. They show what can happen to large Labour majorities when few people vote and Reform voters turn out.

3 of 3
Labour is three for three in Greater Manchester mayoral contests, never below 63%. But the base rate is untested without Burnham on the ballot, and the two most recent by-elections in the North West — Runcorn 2025 and Makerfield 2026 — both put Reform within reach or past the line. Treat the 3/3 with suspicion. That is the honest read. Editorial scoring note: Only the three mayoral contests form the 3/3 sample. Parliamentary by-elections remain contextual comparisons, not successes or failures in that denominator. All three mayoral contests involved Burnham, limiting applicability without him.
2026 Makerfield, Burnham
Makerfield, June: Burnham held the seat with 54.8%, but Reform UK took 34.5% — its best result in a Greater Manchester parliamentary contest. Editorial scoring note: Only the three mayoral contests form the 3/3 sample. Parliamentary by-elections remain contextual comparisons, not successes or failures in that denominator. All three mayoral contests involved Burnham, limiting applicability without him.
2025 Runcorn and Helsby
Runcorn and Helsby: Reform UK overturned a 14,696-vote Labour majority to win the by-election by six votes. Editorial scoring note: Only the three mayoral contests form the 3/3 sample. Parliamentary by-elections remain contextual comparisons, not successes or failures in that denominator. All three mayoral contests involved Burnham, limiting applicability without him.
Show the other 3 cases
2024 Greater Manchester, Burnhamheld
Burnham won a third mayoral term with 63.2% under first-past-the-post.
2021 Greater Manchester, Burnhamheld
Burnham took 67.3% of first preferences — one of the largest mayoral mandates in England.
2017 Greater Manchester, Burnhamheld
The inaugural contest: Burnham won with 63% on first preferences; no second count was needed.

The Read

History favours Bev Craig. Greater Manchester has always voted Labour for mayor, each time by 26 points or more. Craig has run Manchester City Council for five years and is known in the region’s biggest borough, and Labour picked her within four days of the vacancy. Burnham himself kept Makerfield by 20 points, in far worse conditions for Labour than a mayoral race, and his quiet backing should pass more easily to a successor as mayor than to a Westminster candidate. The second-choice system also helps the leader, because Green and Liberal Democrat second choices have usually gone to Labour, not Reform.

The weak point is that Burnham is not on the ballot, and a July by-election is decided by who turns out. In Runcorn, Reform overturned a Labour majority of 14,696 votes when Labour voters stayed home. In Makerfield, Reform reached 34.5% even against the most popular Labour politician in Britain. Every past Labour win here was Burnham’s, so the record has never shown whether these voters belong to the party or to the man. No candidate looks likely to win more than half of first choices, so the second count matters more here than in any earlier Manchester race.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.