Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US midterms6 Oct 2026

Steve Hilton's own party turned on his ad. Will he pull it before 3 November?

Steve Hilton, the Republican running for governor of California, released an ad last week. Two Republicans on the same ballot condemned it.

4 min read

What happened

Steve Hilton, the Republican candidate for California governor, is receiving heavy criticism from members of his own party over a controversial, sexual innuendo-filled campaign ad that has been described as “creepy”.

Steve Hilton released an ad called “Just Try It, California” last week. Hilton is the Republican candidate for governor of California and a former adviser to the British prime minister David Cameron. The ad shows two young women on a bed filling in a ballot for him, with sexual hints.

Two Republicans on the same ballot condemned it. Sonja Shaw, the party’s candidate to run California’s schools, called it “creepy, weird, disturbing garbage”. Michael Gates, the party’s candidate for state attorney general, said he “emphatically” denounced the use of young women as a political tool.

Hilton did not say he would take the ad down. In a video he said most people liked it, and that he understood some were offended.

We were trying to make a point in a provocative way, in satirical way. … I also want to ask you to understand what we are doing.

Steve Hilton, video statement, reported by The Guardian

Hilton is behind Xavier Becerra, the Democrat and former US health secretary, and polls have shown Becerra well ahead. California has not elected a Republican governor since 2004. The vote is on .

Sources: The Guardian, California Secretary of State

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a candidate or party ran a campaign ad that the press called offensive, and members of the candidate’s own party condemned it in public. We found five since 1993, in the US, Britain and Canada. They include a TV ad, an online video, online posts and leaflets, and votes for a national parliament, a Senate seat, a party nomination, a city mayor and local councils.

2 of 5
Two of five candidates took the ad down, both within four days of its release. The other three kept it until the vote. Nobody took an ad down after the first week.
2023 England, Labournot held
: Labour ran an online ad saying Rishi Sunak did not want child sex abusers jailed. Two senior Labour figures asked for it to go. Keir Starmer stood by every word. Labour won 536 new seats on . (BBC News)
2022 Missouri, Greitensnot held
: Eric Greitens, seeking the Republican Senate nomination, released a video about hunting rival Republicans with guns. A rival called it irresponsible. It stayed. He lost on . (Al Jazeera)
Show the other 3 cases
2016 London, Goldsmithnot held
: Zac Goldsmith, Conservative candidate for London mayor, sent leaflets to British Indians saying his rival put family jewellery at risk. A Conservative councillor objected. He lost on . (The Guardian)
2012 Michigan, Hoekstraheld
: Pete Hoekstra, a Republican running for the Senate, aired an ad with an Asian woman speaking broken English. Republican rivals objected. He replaced it on and lost in November. (CBS News)
1993 Canada, Campbellheld
: Prime Minister Kim Campbell’s party ran a TV ad mocking opposition leader Jean Chrétien’s face. Her own candidates condemned it. She pulled it the day she saw it. The party kept 2 seats. (CBC)

The Read

The past points to the ad staying up. Kim Campbell in 1993 and Pete Hoekstra in 2012 took their ads down on the first and fourth day. The other three kept them until the vote, and nobody pulled an ad after the first week. Hilton’s ad is already more than a week old, and on he defended it.

There are reasons for doubt. Only five campaigns came up, in three countries, with very different votes, from local councils to a national parliament. In two of them the ad was the party’s, and the leader took it on. The vote itself looks less open: three of the five lost, and Hilton is behind in a state that has not chosen a Republican governor since 2004.

Sources: The Guardian

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.