Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US midterms6 Oct 2026

Republicans hold the US House by five seats. Will the midterms cost them far more?

Americans elect all 435 members of the House of Representatives on 3 November. Republicans won 220 seats in 2024 and Democrats 215.

5 min read

What happened

A month before the midterms, the Cook Political Report has moved 15 House races toward Democrats and expects them to gain five to 15 seats.

Americans vote on for all 435 seats in the House of Representatives. Analysts have long expected Democrats to win the House. The Cook Political Report, which rates US races, has moved 15 races toward Democrats and expects them to gain five to 15 seats. It now rates the Texas border seat of Republican Monica De La Cruz as a toss-up. (Cook Political Report, via Al Jazeera)

Republicans won 220 seats in 2024 and Democrats 215. If nothing else changes, a net loss of three seats would give Democrats the majority.

An AP-NORC poll puts approval of President Donald Trump at 31%. Trump has asked supporters to vote “like I’m on the ballot“ and has promised $400m to $500m from MAGA Inc, his political group.

Democratic leaders say investigations into the Trump family’s businesses would be a priority if they win. Republicans have more money, with $233.4m in cash against $130.4m for Democrats.

Sources: Al Jazeera, US House history, AP-NORC

The Pattern

We looked for cases where the president’s party ran the House going into a midterm election and the president’s approval was under 50% or not yet measured. We found 16 since 1914 and kept the ten most recent, from 1942 to 2022. The president’s party lost seats every time, and in eight of the ten it lost more than 15.

8 of 10
In eight of ten midterms since 1942 the president's party lost more than 15 House seats. The two smaller losses were 14 seats in 1978 and 9 seats in 2022.
2022 Biden, 2022not held
2022: Democrats under Joe Biden started with 222 seats, and his approval was 40%. They lost 9 seats and the majority, as Republicans won 222. (US House, election statistics)
2018 Trump, 2018held
2018: Republicans under Donald Trump started with 241 seats, and his approval was 41%. They lost 42 seats and the majority, as Democrats won 235. (US House, election statistics)
Show the other 8 cases
2010 Obama, 2010held
2010: Democrats under Barack Obama started with 257 seats, and his approval was 45%. They lost 64 seats and the majority, as Republicans won 242. (US House, election statistics)
2006 Bush, 2006held
2006: Republicans under George W. Bush started with 232 seats, and his approval was 38%. They lost 30 seats and the majority, as Democrats won 233. (US House, election statistics)
1994 Clinton, 1994held
1994: Democrats under Bill Clinton started with 258 seats, and his approval was 46%. They lost 54 seats and the majority, as Republicans won 230. (US House, election statistics)
1978 Carter, 1978not held
1978: Democrats under Jimmy Carter started with 292 seats, and his approval was 49%. They lost 14 seats and kept the majority with 278. (US House, election statistics)
1966 Johnson, 1966held
1966: Democrats under Lyndon Johnson started with 295 seats, and his approval was 44%. They lost 47 seats and kept the majority with 248. (US House, election statistics)
1950 Truman, 1950held
1950: Democrats under Harry Truman started with 263 seats, and his approval was 39%. They lost 28 seats and kept the majority with 235. (US House, election statistics)
1946 Truman, 1946held
1946: Democrats under Harry Truman started with 244 seats, and his approval was 33%. They lost 56 seats and the majority, as Republicans won 246. (US House, election statistics)
1942 Roosevelt, 1942held
1942: Democrats under Franklin Roosevelt started with 267 seats, and Gallup’s table has no approval figure for that year. They lost 45 seats and kept the majority with 222. (US House, election statistics)

The Read

Past midterms point to a big Republican loss. The president’s party lost seats in all ten, and in eight of them it lost 28 or more. The losses came in groups: 9 to 14 seats, 28 to 30, 42 to 47 and 54 to 64. Cook’s forecast of five to 15 seats sits in the lowest group.

Two things could keep the loss small. In 2022, with approval at 40%, Democrats lost only nine seats; Gallup had said before the vote that a party with a thin majority has fewer seats to lose. Republicans now hold 220 seats, the same bare majority Gallup pointed to then. Trump’s 31% also comes from AP-NORC, while Gallup measured the earlier presidents, and the lowest it found was 33% in 1946.

The majority question needs a much smaller loss. A net loss of three seats is enough, and every loss in this list was nine seats or more. Ten midterms cannot cover everything: the six older ones from 1914 to 1938 also fit, and the party kept the House in all six.

Sources: US House history, Gallup

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.