Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US Congress14 Nov 2026

Hakeem Jeffries is set to lead the US House. Will nearly every Democrat back him?

Democrats take over the US House on 3 January with about 258 seats. On 13 November protesters called their leader, Hakeem Jeffries, a traitor.

4 min read

What happened

Leftist protesters interrupted Jeffries multiple times during his Friday event on the main stage. They called him a traitor, accused him of not pushing back enough on the Trump administration and of ignoring younger Democratic voters.

Democrats take control of the US House on . Their leader in the House, Hakeem Jeffries of New York, says they have “258 Democrats and counting”, and NBC News estimates 259 of the 435 seats. On the first day the members elect a Speaker, who runs the House. Each member stands and says a name aloud.

The Congress shall assemble at least once in every year, and such meeting shall begin at noon on the 3d day of January, unless they shall by law appoint a different day.

US Constitution, 20th Amendment, US National Archives

No other Democrat is running against Jeffries. Jamie Raskin, another Democrat, said he is “supporting Hakeem and voting for Hakeem”. Democrats in the House choose their nominee on . A Speaker needs a majority of the members who vote, 218 if all 435 take part, so with 258 seats Jeffries could lose 40 Democratic votes and still win.

Some on the left want him to fight Donald Trump harder. On protesters interrupted Jeffries several times at a party conference in Denver. Greg Casar, who leads the group of left-wing Democrats in the House, said “Every single member here is going to have their individual vote”. By at least nine incoming Democrats had not promised to vote for Jeffries.

Sources: The Guardian (2, 3), PBS NewsHour, NBC News, Axios (2), BBC, Al Jazeera

The Pattern

We looked for cases where the party in charge of the US House, with at least 20 seats more than the 218 needed, elected a new Speaker on the first day of a new Congress. We found ten such votes since 1919, from Frederick Gillett to John Boehner. For each we counted the party’s seats that did not give their nominee a vote on the first ballot. That includes votes for someone else, members who were away and empty seats, and in 2011 the nominee himself, who did not vote.

3 of 10
In three of ten such votes, three or fewer of the party's seats did not go to the new Speaker on the first ballot. In the other seven, between four and 18 did not.
2011 Republicans, John Boehnerheld
: Republicans held 242 seats and John Boehner took over from Nancy Pelosi. He won on the first ballot with 241 votes. The one Republican who did not vote for him was Boehner himself.
1987 Democrats, Jim Wrightnot held
: Democrats held 258 seats, the number Jeffries gives today, and Jim Wright replaced Tip O’Neill. He won on the first ballot with 254 votes, four short of the party’s seats.
Show the other 8 cases
1977 Democrats, Tip O'Neillheld
: Democrats held 292 seats and Tip O’Neill replaced Carl Albert. He won on the first ballot with 290 votes, two short of the party’s seats.
1971 Democrats, Carl Albertnot held
: Democrats held 255 seats and Carl Albert replaced John McCormack. He won on the first ballot with 250 votes, five short of the party’s seats.
1949 Democrats, Sam Rayburnnot held
: Democrats won back the House with 263 seats and Sam Rayburn returned in place of Joseph Martin. He won on the first ballot with 255 votes, eight short of the party’s seats.
1947 Republicans, Joseph Martinheld
: Republicans won the House with 246 seats and Joseph Martin, their leader in opposition, replaced Sam Rayburn. He won on the first ballot with 244 votes, two short.
1935 Democrats, Joseph Byrnsnot held
: Democrats held 322 seats and Joseph Byrns took over after Henry Rainey died. He won on the first ballot with 317 votes. The few votes for others went to members of other parties.
1933 Democrats, Henry Raineynot held
: Democrats held 313 seats and Henry Rainey replaced John Nance Garner. He won on the first ballot with 302 votes, 11 short of the party’s seats.
1925 Republicans, Nicholas Longworthnot held
: Republicans held 247 seats and Nicholas Longworth replaced Frederick Gillett. The party’s progressive wing put up Henry Cooper, who took 13 votes. Longworth won on the first ballot with 229.
1919 Republicans, Frederick Gillettnot held
: Republicans won the House with 240 seats and Frederick Gillett replaced Champ Clark, a Democrat. He won on the first ballot with 228 votes, 12 short of the party’s seats.

The Read

All ten new Speakers won on the first ballot, but few got almost every vote. Only three times, in 1947, 1977 and 2011, did three or fewer of the party’s seats fail to vote for the nominee. With 258 seats, Jeffries needs 255 votes, so he can lose only three, and for this question a member who is away or votes present counts as a lost vote. Several House Democrats told Axios on that they expect “at least a handful” of colleagues to openly oppose him.

There are reasons for doubt. Six of the ten votes took place before 1950, and from 1945 to 1995 only the two parties’ nominees got any votes for Speaker. Votes for other names became common only after 1997, and only the 2011 vote comes from those years. The seat count is not final either: NBC News estimates 259 Democratic seats, and at 259 Jeffries could lose four, which happened once more, in 1987. Among these ten votes, the only time members backed another of their own party was 1925, when the progressive wing put up Henry Cooper.

Sources: Congressional Research Service, PBS NewsHour, Axios, NBC News, US House Historian

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.