Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US Senate4 Oct 2026

Should Mitch McConnell go early? Retiring lawmakers who fell ill have stayed on.

Asked by TIME if Mitch McConnell should resign, Donald Trump said it was a disappointment to many Republicans. McConnell, 84, leaves in January.

4 min read

What happened

In an interview published by TIME on , Donald Trump was asked whether Senator Mitch McConnell should resign. He answered that it was a disappointment to a lot of Republicans.

Donald Trump was asked if Mitch McConnell should resign. In an interview with TIME on , published on , he was asked about videos of McConnell back in the Senate. He answered that it “was a disappointment to a lot of Republicans”, then moved on to another subject.

McConnell, 84, is a Republican senator from Kentucky. He led his party in the Senate until the end of 2024 and is not running again, so his term ends in .

He was away from the Senate from mid-June after a fall at home took him to hospital. He left a rehabilitation centre on . Kentucky’s governor, Andy Beshear, a Democrat, wrote to him in July asking for news on his health and his “ability to hold office”.

McConnell came back to the Senate on and voted. He arrived in a wheelchair and said he would “do my best to be present for tough votes”. The Guardian reported that he has rejected calls to resign before January.

If he did leave early, Kentucky’s governor could not name a replacement. A 2024 state law gave that power away, and the seat would wait for a special election. Republicans hold the Senate 53 to 47.

Sources: TIME, The Independent, Al Jazeera, The Guardian (2)

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a member of the US Congress, or of another parliament with a fixed term, had already said their term would be the last, then fell ill in public in a way that kept them from the work, with no rule that could force them out. We found seven since 2001, all in the US Congress: four senators and three members of the House.

0 of 7
None of seven left office early. Three served until their term ended. Four stayed in office until they died.
2025 US House, Connollynot held
: Gerry Connolly, 75, said he would not run again and gave up his top committee post as his cancer came back. He stayed in office until his death on . (The Guardian)
2024 US House, Grangernot held
: Kay Granger, who had said she would retire, cast her last vote and was later found to be living in a care home. She did not resign and stayed until her term ended in . (The Guardian)
Show the other 5 cases
2023 US Senate, Feinsteinnot held
2023: Dianne Feinstein, 89, retiring, missed two months after shingles. Two House members of her party asked her to resign. She said she would serve out her term and stayed until her death that September. (The Guardian)
2022 US Senate, Leahynot held
: Patrick Leahy, 82, not running again, broke his hip and needed two operations. He came back to the Senate and served until his term ended in . (The Independent)
2013 US House, Youngnot held
: Bill Young, 82, said from a military hospital, where he was treated for a back injury, that he would retire. He did not resign and stayed until his death on . (Roll Call)
2013 US Senate, Lautenbergnot held
: Frank Lautenberg, 89, said he would not seek a sixth term. Poor health kept him away from the Senate for much of the spring. He stayed in office until his death in June. (The Guardian)
2001 US Senate, Thurmondnot held
: Strom Thurmond, 98, who had said he would not run again, collapsed in the Senate chamber. He served the rest of his term and left in . (BBC News)

The Read

History says he stays. None of the seven members of Congress in a similar place left before their term ended, even when members of their own party asked them to go, as happened to Dianne Feinstein in 2023. McConnell has also come back to the Senate since September and is voting again, which points the same way.

The record has limits. All seven cases are from the US Congress since 2001, and we found no checked case from earlier years or from other parliaments. Two senators did leave early because of their health, in 2018 and 2019, but both had years of their term left and a governor of their own party to name the next senator. McConnell has three months left, and Kentucky’s governor can no longer name anyone.

A statement from McConnell’s office setting a date to leave before January would change the answer. Until then, the past cases and his return to the Senate both point to him serving until his term ends.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.