Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US Congress6 Oct 2026

A court refused to drop LaMonica McIver's charges. Will she ask for a rehearing?

US congresswoman LaMonica McIver gave birth on 1 October. By 9 October she must decide how to keep fighting the criminal charges against her.

4 min read

What happened

LaMonica McIver must decide by whether to ask the full appeals court to hear her case again, go to the Supreme Court or let the case go to trial.

LaMonica McIver must decide by how to fight on. She represents New Jersey’s 10th district in the US Congress. Her choice is to ask the full appeals court to hear her case again, to go to the Supreme Court, or to let the case go to trial.

The case comes from a visit to Delaney Hall, an immigration detention centre in Newark, in . She is charged with interfering with an arrest outside it, and the charges carry up to 17 years in prison. She says she is not guilty. She is the only member of Congress the Justice Department has charged.

Her lawyers say the constitution protects members of Congress for their work, under a rule called the speech or debate clause. On three appeals judges refused to drop two of the three charges. They sent the third charge back to the trial judge, and one of the three judges partly disagreed.

We will affirm as to Counts One and Two of the Indictment because prosecution of those charges will not require Congresswoman McIver to answer for any legislative acts.

US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit,

McIver gave birth to her second child on . She is running for re-election this year and plans to return to votes in November, after taking October to rest. She has called the charges “dangerous for all members of Congress on both sides of the aisle, not just for me”.

Sources: The Guardian, US Court of Appeals

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a member of the US Congress lost an appeal to drop criminal charges on the grounds that the constitution protects lawmakers’ work, while running for re-election. We found six members in five court rulings since 1980. John Murphy and Frank Thompson lost in the same ruling.

4 of 5
Four of five times the member asked a higher court before any trial, and once two members went to trial. All three times the court papers show the next step, from 1994 on, it was a request for a rehearing.
2016 US, Menendezheld
: an appeals court refused to drop the charges against senator Robert Menendez. He asked the full court to hear it again, refused in September, then the Supreme Court, refused in . (US Court of Appeals, Third Circuit)
2008 US, Jeffersonheld
: an appeals court refused to drop the charges against congressman William Jefferson. He asked for a rehearing, refused in December, then the Supreme Court, refused in . He lost his seat. (US Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit)
Show the other 4 cases
1994 US, McDadeheld
: the court now hearing the McIver case refused to drop charges against congressman Joseph McDade. He asked the full court to hear it again; four judges agreed, too few. He won his seat that November. (US Court of Appeals, Third Circuit)
1980 US, Myersheld
: an appeals court refused to drop bribery charges against congressman Michael Myers. He asked the Supreme Court, but his trial began three days later. He lost his seat that November. (US Court of Appeals, Second Circuit)
1980 US, Murphynot held
: one appeals ruling refused to drop the charges against congressmen John Murphy and Frank Thompson. The court papers show no further request, and their trial began on . (US Court of Appeals, Second Circuit)
1980 US, Thompsonnot held
Same ruling as John Murphy, . Frank Thompson made no request to a higher court that the papers show, went to trial in November and lost his seat. (US Court of Appeals, Second Circuit)

The Read

Each time the court papers show this step, in 1994, 2008 and 2016, the member of Congress first asked the full appeals court to hear the appeal again. Joseph McDade did it in 1994 in the same court that ruled against McIver. All three requests were refused, and so were all four later requests to the Supreme Court.

There are reasons for doubt. The papers from 1980 show no such request by Michael Myers, John Murphy or Frank Thompson, so this step is visible only three times. McIver’s lawyers can also go straight to the Supreme Court, and she plans to spend October with her new baby. Myers, Murphy, Thompson and Jefferson lost their seats at the next election, while McDade kept his.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.