Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US midterms6 Oct 2026

Abdul El-Sayed beat his party's pick in Michigan. Most who did that then lost.

Barack Obama will rally for Abdul El-Sayed in Detroit on 24 October. Party leaders backed his rival in the Senate primary in August.

5 min read

What happened

Barack Obama will head to Detroit this month to rally with Abdul El-Sayed, a show of establishment support for a progressive insurgent in Michigan, one of the most consequential Senate races in the country.

Former US President Barack Obama will hold a rally in Detroit on . He will appear with Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic candidate for the US Senate in Michigan, and Jocelyn Benson, the Democratic candidate for governor. The rally is on the first day of in-person early voting, 10 days before the election on .

In August El-Sayed won the Democratic primary, the vote that picks the party’s candidate, by less than one point. His rival, Congresswoman Haley Stevens, had the support of Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer and Senator Gary Peters. Her side spent nearly nine times more on advertising, and the pro-Israel group AIPAC and its allies spent a record $30m against him.

Detroit is where the rally matters most. Stevens won Wayne County, which includes the city, with about 51% of the primary vote to El-Sayed’s 45%. More than three-quarters of Detroit’s people are Black, and Obama is still highly popular there.

The seat is open because Peters, a Democrat, is retiring. El-Sayed faces Republican Mike Rogers, a former congressman who lost a Senate race in Michigan in 2024 to Elissa Slotkin, although Donald Trump won the state. A Marist poll of registered voters in late September put El-Sayed ahead by 51% to 44%. The race is one of a handful that will decide which party controls the Senate.

Sources: The Guardian

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a candidate won a party primary for the US Senate against the person the party’s leaders backed, and then faced the general election. We found eight since 2010, seven of them Republicans. In two, the seat was open and it belonged to the candidate’s own party, as in Michigan now.

2 of 8
Two of eight such candidates won in November and six lost. Both winners ran for open seats their party already had. Four of the six losses were by less than five points.
2022 New Hampshire, Bolducnot held
: Don Bolduc beat Chuck Morse, the choice of Governor Chris Sununu and national Republicans, for a Democratic seat. On he lost, 44.4% to 53.5%. (BBC News)
2017 Alabama, Moorenot held
: Roy Moore beat Senator Luther Strange, backed by Donald Trump and Mitch McConnell. After women accused him of abuse when they were teenagers, he lost on , 48.4% to 49.9%. (The Guardian)
Show the other 6 cases
2012 Texas, Cruzheld
: Ted Cruz beat David Dewhurst, backed by Governor Rick Perry, for an open Republican seat. On he won, 56.5% to 40.6%, but with 129,706 fewer votes than Mitt Romney in Texas. (The Guardian)
2010 Delaware, O'Donnellnot held
: Christine O’Donnell beat Mike Castle, the party leaders’ choice, 53% to 47%, for a Democratic seat. On she lost, 40.0% to 56.6%. (The Guardian)
2010 Alaska, Millernot held
: Joe Miller beat Senator Lisa Murkowski. She then ran as a write-in candidate and won on , 39.6% to his 35.6%. (The Guardian)
2010 Colorado, Bucknot held
: Ken Buck beat Jane Norton, backed by most of the state party leaders, for a Democratic seat. On he lost, 46.4% to 48.1%. (The Guardian)
2010 Pennsylvania, Sestaknot held
: Joe Sestak beat Senator Arlen Specter, President Barack Obama’s choice. On he lost, 49.0% to 51.0%. (The Guardian)
2010 Kentucky, Paulheld
: Rand Paul beat Trey Grayson, backed by Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell, 59% to 35%, for an open Republican seat. On he won, 55.7% to 44.2%. (The Guardian)

The Read

Six of the eight candidates lost in November. The two winners, Rand Paul in Kentucky in 2010 and Ted Cruz in Texas in 2012, both ran for open seats their own party already had. That is the situation in Michigan now: the seat is open and it belongs to a Democrat. Of the five who ran from the party out of power in the middle of a president’s term, as El-Sayed does, one won.

There are reasons to read this with care. Seven of the eight were Republicans and five ran in the same year, 2010, so the Democratic side has only one example: Joe Sestak, who lost in Pennsylvania by two points. Four of the six losses were by less than five points, and in Texas in 2012 Cruz won but got fewer votes than his party’s candidate for president. The Marist poll in late September and the result on will show whether Michigan follows the open-seat winners or the others.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.