Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US midterms6 Oct 2026

Republicans are spending $29m in New Hampshire. Will Chris Pappas hold the seat?

Senator Jeanne Shaheen is retiring. Democrat Chris Pappas faces former Republican senator John E. Sununu on 3 November.

5 min read

What happened

Republicans see New Hampshire as their best chance to take a Senate seat from the Democrats, with John E. Sununu against Chris Pappas for the seat of retiring senator Jeanne Shaheen.

Republicans see New Hampshire as their best chance to take a Senate seat from the Democrats. Senator Jeanne Shaheen, a Democrat, said in March that she would not run again. Former Republican senator John E. Sununu faces Democratic congressman Chris Pappas on .

A New York Times poll at the end of September put Sununu 5 points behind. In the same poll 60% of New Hampshire voters disapproved of President Donald Trump, and 65% of voters outside both parties. Among those voters Sununu led Pappas by 10 points on good character.

Outside groups have spent more than $50m in a state with fewer than one million registered voters. The Senate Leadership Fund put $17m behind Sununu, No Going Back PAC $10m and AFP Action more than $2m. Senate Majority PAC put $10m behind Pappas.

Sources: TIME

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a midterm Senate seat came open on the side of the party opposite the president, and the president’s party ran someone who had already won a statewide post. In each, the governor came from the other party to the senator leaving. We found ten since 1918, all in years when the president’s approval was under 50% or not yet measured.

7 of 10
In seven of ten open seats the party opposite the president kept the seat. The president's party took it three times, twice with a sitting governor as its candidate.
2022 Pennsylvania, Fettermannot held
2022: Republican senator Toomey retired. Democrat Fetterman, the lieutenant governor, beat Oz 51.2% to 46.3% and took the seat for his party. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2022 North Carolina, Beasleyheld
2022: Republican senator Burr retired. Democrat Beasley, a former chief justice who had twice won statewide, lost to Budd 47.3% to 50.5%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
Show the other 8 cases
2010 Ohio, Fisherheld
2010: Republican senator Voinovich did not run. Democrat Fisher, the lieutenant governor, lost to Portman 39.4% to 56.8%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2010 Missouri, Carnahanheld
2010: Republican senator Bond did not run. Democrat Carnahan, Missouri’s secretary of state, lost to Blunt 40.6% to 54.2%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2010 Kentucky, Conwayheld
2010: Republican senator Bunning did not run. Democrat Conway, the state attorney general, lost to Paul 44.2% to 55.7%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2006 Maryland, Steeleheld
2006: Democratic senator Sarbanes did not run. Republican Steele, the lieutenant governor, lost to Cardin 44.2% to 54.2%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1994 Wyoming, Sullivanheld
1994: Republican senator Wallop did not run. Democrat Sullivan, governor since 1987, lost to Thomas 39.3% to 58.9%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1978 Oklahoma, Borennot held
1978: Republican senator Bartlett stood down over his health. Democrat Boren, the sitting governor, won 65.5% to 32.9% and took the seat. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1978 Nebraska, Exonnot held
1978: Republican senator Curtis did not run. Democrat Exon, the sitting governor, won 67.7% to 32.3% and took the seat. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1918 West Virginia, Watsonheld
1918: Republican senator Goff did not run. Democrats chose Watson, a former senator for the state. Republican Elkins won; the margin is not on open pages. (Biographical Directory of the US Congress)

The Read

Past races favour Pappas. In seven of ten open seats like this one, the party opposite the president kept the seat. The president’s party won three times: with sitting governors in Nebraska and Oklahoma in 1978, by 35 and 33 points, and with Fetterman in Pennsylvania in 2022. A former senator ran only once, in West Virginia in 1918, and lost.

Three of the ten races took place on the same day in 2010, and two each in 1978 and 2022, so one national mood often moved several of them together. The losing margins of the president’s party ran from 3.2 to 19.6 points. A 5-point poll gap sits near the narrow end, which is why the margin question is closer than the winner question.

Polls in October and the result on will settle both questions.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.