Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
US midterms6 Oct 2026

Jon Husted faces Sherrod Brown in Ohio. Appointed senators like him usually win.

Former senator Sherrod Brown faces Senator Jon Husted, appointed in January 2025, in Ohio's special election on 3 November.

5 min read

What happened

Nearly 1,400 people were laid off at a former Navistar truck plant in south-west Ohio before a Trump rally, in a state where Jon Husted faces Sherrod Brown for a Senate seat.

Nearly 1,400 people lost their jobs at a former Navistar truck plant in south-west Ohio. The cuts came on the Wednesday before a rally by President Donald Trump, and they wipe out a year of job growth in the Dayton area.

Republican senator Jon Husted faces Democrat Sherrod Brown, a former senator who lost his seat two years ago. Husted was appointed to the Senate on , and this is his first election for the seat. The race could decide control of the Senate.

Only 17% of Americans approve of how Trump is handling the cost of living. At his rally in Vandalia he did not talk about prices or the job cuts. He promised $5,000 cheques if Republicans win both chambers of Congress.

Husted has broken with Trump in public over the war with Iran, as have Republican candidates in Iowa and Michigan.

Sources: The Independent, US Senate, Al Jazeera

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a senator appointed from the president’s party ran in a special election for the rest of the term in a midterm year, with the president under 50% approval or not yet measured. We found 26 since 1914, all equal on what we could check, and kept the ten most recent, from 1934 to 2022. The appointed senator won 19 of the 26, and 9 of the 10.

9 of 10
Nine of the ten most recent appointed senators won. Over the full list since 1914 it is 19 of 26; the seven losses all came before 1946.
2022 California, Padillaheld
2022: Democrat Padilla, appointed in after twice winning statewide as secretary of state, won the special election 60.9% to 39.1%. Biden’s approval was 40%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2018 Mississippi, Hyde-Smithheld
2018: Republican Hyde-Smith, appointed in , nearly tied the first round, then won the run-off on 53.6% to 46.4%. Trump’s approval was 41%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
Show the other 8 cases
2014 Hawaii, Schatzheld
2014: Democrat Schatz, appointed in after winning statewide as lieutenant governor, won 69.8% to 27.7%. Obama’s approval was 44%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
2010 New York, Gillibrandheld
2010: Democrat Gillibrand, appointed in , won the special election 59.6% to 33.3%. Obama’s approval was 45%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1966 Virginia, Byrdheld
1966: Democrat Byrd, appointed in , won the special election 53.3% to 37.4%. Johnson’s approval was 44%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1950 Connecticut, Bentonheld
1950: Democrat Benton, appointed in , beat Prescott Bush by 1,102 votes, 50.1% to 49.9%. Truman’s approval was 39%. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1942 West Virginia, Rosiernot held
1942: Democrat Rosier, appointed in , lost the special election to Republican Shott, 47.7% to 52.3%. His party also lost the state’s other Senate race that day. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1938 Alabama, Hillheld
: Democrat Hill, appointed in , won the special election; the April vote count is not on open pages. He won a full term that November. (Biographical Directory of the US Congress)
1934 Wyoming, O'Mahoneyheld
1934: Democrat O’Mahoney, appointed in , won 56.9% to 43.1% against Carter, who had represented the whole state in Congress. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)
1934 New Mexico, Hatchheld
1934: Democrat Hatch, appointed in , won the special election 54.8% to 44.7% against Dillon. (Office of the Clerk, election statistics)

The Read

Past races favour Husted. Since 1934, nine of ten appointed senators from the president’s party won their special midterm election, six of them by 10 points or more. Over the full list since 1914 the count is 19 of 26, and all seven losses came before 1946, so the most recent ten look stronger than the whole list.

The one loss in the recent ten and the closest win both came in hard years for the president’s party: West Virginia in 1942, and Connecticut in 1950 by 1,102 votes. Brown is a former senator who has won Ohio before. Only three past races had an opponent who had won statewide, and the appointed senator won two of them. Approval of Trump on living costs, at 17%, has no match in the past races.

The result on settles both questions.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.