Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
Scotland19 Nov 2026

Why Scotland's new Islay ferry still needs weeks after handover to carry passengers

A shipyard in Turkey has handed over MV Loch Indaal, the second of four new ferries for CalMac, after delays. It still has to sail to Scotland.

4 min read

What happened

The second of four new CalMac ferries being built by a Turkish shipyard has been formally handed over after a series of delays.

A new ferry goes through three steps before it carries passengers. It sails home from the shipyard, the crew learns the ship, and it practises coming in to the piers. MV Loch Indaal was handed over at the Cemre shipyard in Turkey to CMAL, the ferry owner run by the Scottish government, which leases it to the operator CalMac. The trip to Scotland should take about two weeks.

The handover was first due in , then at the end of October. On the ferry did not yet have final approval from the Maritime and Coastguard Agency, the UK body that checks ship safety. On CMAL said it now has certificates from the agency and from Lloyd’s Register.

The four ferries cost about £200m in total. In June CMAL paid the last £23m for the three unfinished ones, and the Scottish government has since agreed to pay £20m more for extra costs. Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn promised that the ferry will start work “at the earliest opportunity”, without a date. It will serve Islay with its sister ship, MV Isle of Islay.

Once the vessel arrives in Scotland, she will undergo crew familiarisation and local operational trials before entering service alongside her sister vessel, MV Isle of Islay.

CMAL, 18 November 2026

Sources: BBC (2, 3, 4), CMAL

The Pattern

We looked for cases where a shipyard handed over the second or a later ferry of a series to an operator that sails to or from Britain. We found seven such ferries from 2012 to 2025. Each one had to sail from the yard to its home port before its first passengers. We counted the days from handover to that first trip with passengers.

4 of 7
Four of seven times, an operator carried its first passengers on the second or a later ferry of a series within 74 days of handover. Three times it took 111 to 117 days.
2024 Guillaume de Normandie, Brittanynot held
: a yard in Weihai, China, handed Brittany Ferries its second hybrid ferry of a series. It reached Portsmouth on and carried its first passengers on day 116.
2023 P&O Liberté, P&O Ferriesnot held
: a yard in Guangzhou, China, handed P&O Ferries its second new hybrid ferry for Dover. It began trips with passengers and freight from Dover to Calais on day 111.
Show the other 5 cases
2022 Santoña, Brittany Ferriesheld
: Santoña was handed over in Weihai, two months ahead of schedule. Its first commercial trip, Portsmouth to Santander, left on day 71.
2021 Salamanca, Brittany Ferriesnot held
: Brittany Ferries took Salamanca, its second ferry of the series, in Weihai. It first sailed from Portsmouth to Bilbao with more than 600 passengers on day 117.
2020 Stena Embla, Stena Lineheld
: Stena Embla was handed over in Weihai. After a first trip on another route, it carried passengers on its own Belfast to Liverpool route on day 66.
2020 Stena Edda, Stena Lineheld
: Stena Edda was handed over in Weihai and reached Belfast Lough after 34 days at sea. It made its first trip, Birkenhead to Belfast, on day 54.
2012 Spirit of France, P&O Ferriesheld
: after delays over vibration and a storm, a yard in Finland handed over Spirit of France. It reached Dover in four days and sailed to Calais on day 16.

The Read

Most of the time went on the trip home and the first weeks in port. Stena Edda spent 34 days at sea from China and sailed 13 days after reaching Belfast Lough. Spirit of France came from Finland in four days and sailed 12 days after reaching Dover. MV Isle of Islay, the first ferry of this series, took 31 days to reach Scotland, though CMAL expected about two weeks. It carried passengers 37 days after arriving.

There are reasons for doubt. Five of the seven ferries came from the same yard in China, and all seven are large ferries, much bigger than Loch Indaal, which takes 450. For CalMac’s own earlier sister ferries, Lochinvar and Catriona, no first sailing date can be found on open pages. The trip from Turkey is shorter than from China, and the only ferry here with a delayed handover and a short trip, Spirit of France, was the quickest.

Sources: NI Ferry Site, BBC (2), Kent Online, CMAL, CalMac (2), Motorship

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.