Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch

Northern Ireland teachers begin a work-to-rule. Past ones lasted over a month.

All five teaching unions in Northern Ireland will stop unpaid extra work from Monday 28 September, in a dispute over how much work teachers do.

4 min read

What happened

The Northern Ireland Teachers’ Council, which represents the five teaching unions, said on that industrial action short of a strike over workload will begin on Monday .

The action follows failed talks on how to cut teachers’ workload. Under union instructions seen by BBC News NI, teachers stop unpaid extra work done out of goodwill. They go to only one meeting or parents’ event outside school hours each term. They also refuse to cover for absent colleagues beyond their contracts, and they stop supervising public exams.

The dispute is about how to carry out the 27 recommendations of an independent review of teacher workload. The unions won that review in the pay deal of .

The employers say eight of 11 open issues are agreed in principle. The Teachers’ Negotiating Committee, which speaks for the employers, asked for four more weeks. The unions said no.

Education Minister Paul Givan said he was disappointed and that there was room to reach a deal. Stormont has no agreed budget for this year. Since a deadline passed in August, officials have been spending up to 95% of last year’s money without ministers’ agreement.

Sources: BBC (2, 3)

The Pattern

We looked for times since 2012 when teachers’ or head teachers’ unions across a whole UK nation started action short of a strike, such as a work-to-rule. For each we asked whether the action was still in place 31 days after it began. We found ten and use nine, because one has no known end date. The closest are shown first. All nine were still in place a month after they began. Four are in Northern Ireland with the same employer side, so they are not fully separate, and two of those, both in 2022, ended with one deal. The 2017 and 2022 Northern Ireland disputes ran mostly while Stormont had no working Executive. The 2025 case and this one have a minister in post.

9 of 9
All nine cases were still in place 31 days after they began, and eight of nine after 90 days. The quickest end, on day 53, was the closest case: the same five unions and the same minister in 2025.
2025 Northern Ireland, five unionsheld
: all five Northern Ireland teaching unions restarted action short of a strike over pay and workload. On they accepted a revised offer with a workload review, which ended the action. (bbc.co.uk)
2022 Northern Ireland, four unionsheld
: four Northern Ireland teaching unions began coordinated action short of a strike over pay. It ran until all five unions accepted a pay deal on . (BBC News)
Show the other 7 cases
2022 Northern Ireland, NASUWTheld
: NASUWT began action short of a strike in Northern Ireland after rejecting a pay offer. It ended with the same deal of as the action of the other unions. (BBC News)
2017 Northern Ireland, three unionsheld
: INTO began boycotting school inspections as part of action short of a strike, and two more unions joined within ten days. Members backed a deal ending the dispute on . (BBC News)
2012 NUT and NASUWT, England, Walesheld
: the NUT and NASUWT began a joint work-to-rule in England and Wales over pay and pensions. On it was still going, and the dispute went on to strikes in 2013. (BBC News)
2023 England, NASUWTheld
: NASUWT began action short of a strike in English schools after the other unions had accepted a 6.5% pay rise. No end was announced before its mandate ran out in . (gov.uk)
2023 Wales, NAHT Cymruheld
: head teachers in NAHT Cymru began working a 9am to 5pm day and refusing extra meetings. Members accepted a pay and workload offer on and the action ended that week. (BBC News)
2012 Scotland, SSTAheld
: the Scottish Secondary Teachers’ Association began working to contract over pension changes. On it suspended the action without a deal, as a gesture before talks between governments. (BBC News)
2016 Scotland, EISheld
: Scotland’s largest teaching union, the EIS, began working to contract on exam-related workload. It suspended the action on after agreement to drop compulsory unit assessments. (BBC News)

The Read

The record says this kind of action lasts. In all nine cases it was still in place a month after it began, and eight of the nine ran past three months. Action short of a strike usually costs members no pay, which removes one reason to settle fast. The disputes in the record ended only when a new offer was put to members.

This case is closer to a deal than most. The employer side says eight of 11 issues are agreed in principle. The closest case in the record, with the same five unions and the same minister in 2025, ended on day 53 once a revised offer and a workload review were on the table.

Money weighs on the other side. Stormont still has no agreed budget, and the unions want a plan for all 27 recommendations that is paid for. Any deal would also go to union members before the action is called off.

Disclaimer

Hunch works only from sources that are publicly available, and publishes on the basis of analysis of that material. We do not form an editorial opinion or take sides, we give a simpler and wider view of news that already exists. If information in a source we used was inaccurate, distorted, or later disputed but had already entered our analysis, Hunch accepts no liability for that. Predictions are not advice. Phase 1 markets use Hunch Points, not money.

Published by Hunch under the Editorial Code. Complaints and corrections: /contact/.

Comment

Comments are moderated. Members post under their prediction record.