History. No count: in past draft bills the government gave its view only in a written answer after the report.
Hunch. Ministers said on 16 November they will take the committee's evidence seriously, and in past draft bills they answered only after the report came out.
The ministers market resolves on GOV.UK and Hansard: YES if by 23:59 UK time on 22 January 2027 a minister says the government will remove or change that wording, while general words such as 'take all evidence seriously' or a promise to consider the report are NO. BBC and The Guardian reports are the backup.
We looked for cases where a committee of MPs and peers reviewed a draft UK bill after a witness spoke out in public against one part of it. We found four such reports since 2011, on libel, Lords reform, internet records and online safety. The critics were newspapers, a church leader, phone companies and charities. None of them was an expert the government had quoted in support.