Tue, 19 May 2026
Hunch
Market14 Nov 2026

Will another Democrat get a vote for Speaker on the first ballot?

BinaryResolves 3 Jan 2027
History10%
Hunch40%
Your forecast
  • Yes
  • No
Resolves 3 Jan 2027
Why these numbers

History. In one of ten past cases a member of the majority party other than its nominee got votes from his own party on the first ballot: 13 votes for Henry Cooper in 1925.

Hunch. On 13 November several House Democrats told Axios they expect at least a handful of colleagues to openly oppose Jeffries on the floor.

How this resolves

The other-Democrat market resolves on the same Clerk roll call: YES if at least one vote on the first ballot goes to a Democrat other than Hakeem Jeffries, with party taken from the official directory of members of Congress. Votes of present and votes for Republicans or people of other parties do not count, and The Guardian and Al Jazeera are the backup.

The pattern behind it

3 of 10
In three of ten such votes, three or fewer of the party's seats did not go to the new Speaker on the first ballot. In the other seven, between four and 18 did not.

We looked for cases where the party in charge of the US House, with at least 20 seats more than the 218 needed, elected a new Speaker on the first day of a new Congress. We found ten such votes since 1919, from Frederick Gillett to John Boehner. For each we counted the party's seats that did not give their nominee a vote on the first ballot. That includes votes for someone else, members who were away and empty seats, and in 2011 the nominee himself, who did not vote.