History. Five of six times there was a counted vote between a leader and a challenger in the US Congress, the challenger got more than 18% of the votes, and once less.
Hunch. On 14 November Al Jazeera counted at least 10 Democratic senators who say they will not back Schumer, which is already about 18% of the caucus.
The vote share market counts only if Senate Democrats hold a vote between Schumer and Van Hollen before 3 January 2027 and the count is made public, and it is void otherwise. It resolves YES if Van Hollen gets more than 18.2% of all votes cast, blank and 'present' included, by the caucus statement, confirmed by The Guardian or NBC News.
We looked for cases where a member of one party in the US Congress ran in public against that party's sitting leader in the party's own vote for leader. We found ten since 1964, four of them in the Senate. We counted the days from the challenge to the vote, or to the leader giving up. Schumer was challenged on 12 November, and 1 December is day 19.